Skip to main content

Translating VTSAX for Canadians

Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash
Like most of you, I've read The Simple Path to Wealth and thought "Wow! Now to head to Vanguard and set up my account! Hey, WTF??" If you haven't read the book, feel free to read it in blog form on the authors blog right here.


Probably a proper rite of passage for any Canadian pursuing FIRE is to hear about the message from an American blog or podcast and then immediately google VTSAX only to realise that the mutual fund is not offered to Canadians. To add further insult to injury we can't even open a Vanguard account. ....well fuck you too, Vanguard. Just kidding!

Vanguard is Canadian-friendly - very much so. They have superb products available for Canadians to buy in the form of ETF's from the numerous stock exchanges around the globe. This certainly adds complexity to the average Jane or Joe trying to buy their first index fund but not greatly so. In fact, I keep it VERY simple in this blog post called the 7 Simple Steps to Investing for Canadians in 2020. I will be keeping that thing updated so feel free to check back often and feel free to pass that around the internet, you'll do me and my blog a big favour, not too mention the person on the receiving end obtaining such valuable advice, all for free!

Okay, now that the rambling and shameless self-promotion is out of the way, let's look at how to buy the Total US Stock Market Index, otherwise known as VTSAX. As I hinted above, we cannot buy this in mutual fund form from Vanguard, we have to look at ETF's only. For the same reasons as JL Collins, I will be focusing only on Vanguard products.

Option #1 - VCN [0.06% MER]

Okay, this ETF isn't American at all, VCN is actually Vanguard's Total Canadian Stock Market Index. Some Canadians might think this is the Canadian equivalent version so instead of buying every single piece of a public company in the US, you're doing the same thing in Canada with Canadian companies. Totally the same, right?

Ehhhh, no. This is an excellent ETF to invest in but its not at all the same thing. If you have read JL Collin's book you'll know he recommends buying the entire US market with one fund and leaving it there. While I think this advice comes with certain risks, it is especially risky if you do this with VCN because we're not as big or as diversified as the US. Canada has several amazing companies and very profitable businesses that you should want to invest in but there is enough reputable and evidence-based research coming from this guy that we ought to know better than to put all our eggs in one basket.

Option #2 - VUN [0.46% MER inside TFSA or RRSP, 0.16% in a taxable account]

Here is the literal translation for Canadians. VUN holds the exact same thing VTSAX does, there is no difference besides the under-the-hood mechanics of holding the US stock market in Canadian dollars which is stuff we don't need to fret about. There's nothing else you have to worry about unless that MER seems incredibly high. If it does, I've got some news for you - it sucks to be Canadian sometimes.

As a Canadian investing in the US companies with Canadian ETFs and/or with Canadian dollars, we get hit with a foreign withholding tax. Essentially, foreigners to the US are treated to an additional tax consequence of 0.30% when a US company pays a dividend. This is why Vanguard's posted MER of 0.16% is actually 0.46% to us Canadians. This post by FrugalTrader of Million Dollar Journey (one of the best blogs about Canadian investing) gets into even more detail if you're interested but since we're on a simple path, we're gonna leave it alone and not think too much about this issue. This is the main way to buy a VTSAX equivalent for Canadians, especially in our TFSA.

The taxable account is the last account any Canadian should fill up on their journey to FIRE. I'm guessing since you're reading this article that you're likely new to DIY investing and you might be wondering, "I kinda want that 0.16% MER, how do I get that?" It's when you claim a foreign withholding tax credit on your Canadian tax return against other taxes you owe. It's not the Simple Path JL Collins (or I) choose so stick with the tax shelters (TFSA and RRSP) that are significantly better for creating wealth and don't fret about achieving a lower MER and trying to claim this until you've maxed both of those out.

Option #3 - VTI [0.03% MER]

VTI is VTSAX but in ETF form. Held in US dollars, this is the fund that Canadians want to hold in their RRSP if they want to achieve the ultra-low MER dream while avoiding the foreign withholding tax mentioned before. Since Canada and the US have a tax treaty for each others retirement accounts, Canadians have the option of converting their Canadian dollars into US dollars and then buying VTI from the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).

Converting your CAD to USD is quite expensive, although made much cheaper using Norbert's Gambit, a cool-sounding name for a fairly boring process. The manoeuvre does come with some risks, let's put it on the shelf for now and talk about it in a different post because it's not the Simple Path we've signed up for.

Option #4 - VEQT or your All-in-One Asset Allocation Fund [0.50% MER give or take]

I'm going to go out on a limb here and say this is probably the simplest way to invest. While the MER is quite high for registered accounts (like TFSA and RRSP) we can't ignore how absolutely freaking simple this is to have worldwide exposure. VEQT only holds 40% of its value in Total US Stock Market, so it's not quite the same as JL Collins' advice but it's partly there. 

Once you hold $100,000 or more an a single registered account, you might want to think about breaking up VEQT into smaller parts. This will add complexity to your life in the form of rebalancing and calculating all sorts of different MER's in different accounts and blah blah blah. All-in-One funds are designed to just stop that kind of worry and just go with the flow so sticking with VEQT is a simple path to wealth.

It's not the end of the world to pay an MER of 0.50%. Half of it isn't even your fault, you're just a Canadian doing the right thing by diversifying your portfolio, a move that will surely be well worth the price. Even if you're one of my readers with 6 figure registered accounts, I still wouldn't shame you for choosing the simpler path. Less time agonizing over your finances is ALWAYS a good thing. It's like calculating dog years - I'm certain for every year you spend finding the best way to invest is the equivalent of losing 7 years in real life.

Closing Thoughts

We all know and understand that the more you tinker with your investments the more likely you are to damage your long-term gains. Changing your mind and bouncing back and forth can be costly not only in processing fees but also if you happen to take your money out of the market even if just for a day. Remember, the investment firm Fidelity even released data showing some of the best performing investors were estate accounts because dead people can't tinker with their accounts. It is at this time I would like to adopt the phrase:


"Invest like the Dead"

Summary: 
- VCN isn't a viable strategy to copy the Simple Path to Wealth, although it could have a place in your portfolio. 
- VUN is how Canadians buy VTSAX. It simply costs us $46/year for every $10k invested, instead of $3/year for Americans buying VTSAX.
- VUN is great for TFSAs and taxable accounts but VTI is a great additional option for RRSPs with more seasoned investors with a high balance. You'll get that $3/year American value by doing so!
- VEQT is the most diverse Simple Path to Wealth but only holds 40% of its value in Total US Stock Market. 
- JL Collins recommends 100% US stocks to Americans - the choice is yours as a Canadian to either stick with VUN or opt for VEQT - the fee is the same unless you perform Norbert's Gambit in your RRSP accounts.

Thanks for reading! I hope this post as helped. Feel free to leave me comments here or where I link this article online. I respond to everybody!

Ryan Myricks

You can email me here: canadianfire1@gmail.com

Comments

  1. Excellent breakdown, Ryan! Where was this post in 2014 when I first discovered Mr. Money Mustache and JL Collins? 😆

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Ryan,
    Great article.
    In the section: "Option #2 - VUN", you stated: "0.46% MER inside TFSA or RRSP, 0.16% in a taxable account".
    I thought it was 0.16% for RRSP and 0.46% in the taxable account.
    Cheers,

    ReplyDelete

Post a comment

Most Popular Posts

The Best Phone Plan in Canada

We the community use Public Mobile. Let me tell you why.
** My referral code is at the bottom of the page. Please consider using it to help support my blog and my mission. Last Update: Jun 2020 **
You'll get $10 credit!

Here's a list of why Public Mobile is the best phone plan out there. FYI - I'm not paid by Public Mobile, I just really like them and so does the FIRE community. Let us help you see the light.

#1 They use the Telus network, which is very, very good. Check your phones compatibility here. For reference, I use a Google Pixel 2 XL and my wife uses an iPhone 6. 

#2 Yes, you can port your number.

#3 Three very cheap plans that should cover 99% of Canadians AND their businesses needs: *Ontario bias but I've checked and most provinces are identical*
$15/month - unlimited international text, 100 minutes, unlimited incoming calls, 250mb of data$25/month - unlimited international text, unlimited nationwide calling, 1gb of data$40/month - unlimited international text, unl…

The Requirements of FIRE

I don't want to gatekeep the FIRE movement or anything... but.... okay well you'll read this article and realise I really kinda-sorta want to but for hopefully altruist reasons. 

The reason for such gatekeeping is to fix the blurred line between what the FIRE movement is and what is isn't.

7 Simple Steps to Investing with Vanguard All-in-One Funds

You've been thinking about investing for a while but you've been held back by several excuses. Some of these are legitimate (everybody says to do this or that... but is that right?) and some of them are pathetic (I'm not sure right now is a good time to buy.... just look at the news!). I have some very simple advice for you:


Fuck the news and fuck the piles of noise everybody is "adding" to the "conversation." 
It's simple, you already know you need to invest and you probably have the cash sitting somewhere else collecting a garbage interest rate. The more complex you make it, the more easily these websites, robo advisors, banks and mutual fund companies can profit from you. I have nothing to gain from you - so I have this really easy step process because I haven't been bought to make it more complex or sell you additional garbage. No must-use language from advertisers, no paywall and no book. It's almost like I want to do this. You'll see…

Are you Turning the FIRE Movement into a Fad?

I think I say this often around here - I believe I have written the most unpopular article to date. I'm sure this article will twist several panties into a bunch. Prepare your soft feelings.
Are all these wusses saving 10-49% on the path to FIRE actually a part of the movement? Or are they just big softies ruining the hardcoreness of the Mustachian lifestyle that runs parallel with the mainstream FIRE movement? Spreading the gospel that FI is the answer and RE is the devil is complete bullshit. What the fuck people?
This post is part 2 of the continuation of "The Requirements of FIRE"

A book came out in 1989 explaining how to really not give a shit about your finances and still be fine for retirement. It was called The Wealthy Barber by David Chilton and it is the best selling personal finance book in Canada ever since. The book basically states this: save 10% of your income and don't incur any other debt besides a mortgage. Put your income into well run mutual funds (w…